@CoolCrab I disagree that “want to go” divided by “been there” is the same as a review since entries can be presented in an unfair and even deceptive light. Some entries seem really nice but are actually pretty boring to visit or are inacessible.
I agree that Google Maps is a great source for actual reviews, even if they’re usually be a bit skewed and might not match the interests of AO users.
In some ways I think AO competes with Trip Advisor/Google Maps in these categories, i.e. having a webpage instead of just the book. But if there is no interest in it then of course it shouldn’t happen.
There is also the constant balance between having a popular site with many features vs. pointing to places that are actually obscure enough.